18 Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza Sauce Recipe Ignite Your Passion For Cooking!

Published on: Mar 18, 2024

Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza is a delicious and hearty pizza that combines the flavors of a traditional Italian hero sandwich with the convenience of a pizza. The hero sandwich, also known as a hoagie or sub, is a popular sandwich in the United States, typically made with Italian meats, cheese, and vegetables. Papa John's has taken this classic sandwich to the next level by incorporating their signature pizza sauce into the recipe. In this article, we will delve into the secret behind Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza sauce recipe and how you can recreate it at home.

Jump to Recipe

1 of 20

Papa John’s Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomato Puree, Water, Sugar, Sunflower Oil, Lemon Juice

PAPA JOHNS GARLIC SAUCE | Recipe in 2023 | Papa johns garlic sauce ...

Papa John’s Pizza - 10 Photos & 45 Reviews - Pizza - Clairemont - San ...

Papa John's Pizza | Julie's Dining Club

Papa John’s is known for their delicious pizza, but one of the best parts of their pizza is their signature pizza sauce. Made with vine-ripened tomatoes and a secret blend of herbs and spices, this sauce adds the perfect balance of tangy and savory flavors to any pizza. And the best part? You can now recreate this sauce at home with our top 20 Beer Can Chicken recipes.

2 of 20

Papa John’s Garlic Sauce

Main Ingredients: Margarine, Garlic Powder, Salt

Papa John's Is Now Selling 8-Pound Jugs of Their Garlic Sauce | Garlic ...

PAPA JOHNS GARLIC SAUCE | Recipe in 2022 | Papa johns garlic sauce ...

No pizza is complete without a side of Papa John’s famous garlic sauce. Made with a special blend of garlic, butter, and Parmesan cheese, this dipping sauce is the perfect accompaniment to any pizza. But why stop at just dipping pizza in this sauce? With our top 20 Beer Can Chicken recipes, you can use this sauce to marinate and baste your chicken for a deliciously juicy and flavorful meal.

3 of 20

Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce

Main Ingredients: Salted Butter, Garlic Powder, Salt

Best Papa John's Garlic Sauce Recipe - CopyKat Recipes | Recipe ...

Garlic Dipping Sauce in 2021 | Pizza recipes homemade, Dipping sauce ...

Make your own Better Than Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce | Recipe ...

Looking for a healthier alternative to Papa John’s garlic sauce? Look no further than our homemade version! Made with Greek yogurt, garlic, and a touch of honey, this sauce is a lighter and guilt-free option to enjoy with your pizza or use as a marinade for your Beer Can Chicken. It’s a win-win situation.

4 of 20

Better Than Papa John's Garlic Dipping Sauce

Main Ingredients: Salted Butter, Garlic Powder, Salt

If you've ever wondered how to make garlic butter sauce, wonder no more ...

Garlic dipping sauces, Cooking recipes, Recipes

Looking to take your garlic dipping sauce game to the next level? Our recipe is not only better than Papa John’s, but it’s also customizable to your taste preferences. Add a bit more heat with some red pepper flakes, or throw in some fresh herbs for an extra burst of flavor. The possibilities are endless, and your taste buds will thank you.

5 of 20

Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Plum Tomatoes, Red Bell Pepper, Garlic, Tomato Paste

Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Honey and Birch

5-minute Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Crazy for Crust

While Papa John’s pizza sauce is undeniably delicious, making your own homemade pizza sauce allows you to control the ingredients and customize the flavors to your liking. Our recipe calls for simple pantry staples like canned tomatoes, garlic, and Italian seasoning, making it easy and budget-friendly to whip up a batch whenever a pizza craving strikes.

6 of 20

The Perfect Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Unsalted Butter, Onions, Garlic Cloves

The best easy pizza sauce! Made with a few simple ingredients, quick ...

Easy to make home canned pizza sauce using fresh tomatoes. Step by step ...

Perfect Homemade Pizza Dough Recipe | Little Spice Jar

Looking for the ultimate pizza sauce recipe? Look no further. Our recipe combines the best of both worlds – the tanginess of Papa John’s sauce and the simplicity of our homemade recipe. With a few secret ingredients, this sauce is the perfect balance of flavors and will have you wondering why you ever settled for store-bought pizza sauce.

7 of 20

Ultimate Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Onions, Celery, Garlic Cloves

Pizza Sauce recipe (3 versions) | RecipeTin Eats

Ultimate Pizza Sauce | It is thick, saucy, spicy and delicious. I'll ...

Kitchen Basics: How To Make The Best Pizza Sauce

Best Pizza Sauce Recipe - Sauce Fanatic | Recipe | Pizza sauce recipe ...

If you’re a fan of a thicker and chunkier pizza sauce, our ultimate pizza sauce recipe is for you. Made with fresh tomatoes, onions, and a blend of Italian herbs, this sauce is packed with flavor and has the perfect texture to hold up under all your favorite pizza toppings. Trust us, once you try this sauce, you’ll never go back to the store-bought stuff.

8 of 20

5-Minute Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomato Sauce, Tomato Paste, Garlic Cloves, Dried

5-MINUTË PIZZA SAUCË | Aimer La Cuisine

5 minute pizza sauce | Recipe | Food, Cooking recipes, Recipes

5-minute pizza sauce, bright and simple - Blossom to Stem

Short on time? No problem. Our 5-minute pizza sauce recipe is a game-changer. With just a few simple ingredients and a blender, you can have homemade pizza sauce in a matter of minutes. This sauce is perfect for those busy weeknights when you want to make a homemade pizza without all the fuss.

9 of 20

Best Ever Italian Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Fresh Oregano Leaves, Garlic

Authentic Italian Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Christina's Cucina

Authentic Italian Pizza Sauce and Sicilian Pizza | What's Cookin ...

Looking for an authentic Italian pizza sauce? Look no further than our best ever Italian pizza sauce. Made with San Marzano tomatoes, garlic, and herbs, this sauce will transport you straight to Italy with every bite. It’s rich, flavorful, and the perfect base for any pizza.

10 of 20

Super Easy Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Garlic, Italian Seasoning

Pizza Sauce recipe (3 versions) - Yummy Recipe

Copycat Pizzeria Pizza Sauce Recipe • Food Folks and Fun

5-Ingredient & 3-Minute Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe

If you’re new to making pizza sauce or just looking for a foolproof recipe, our super easy pizza sauce is the one for you. With just four ingredients and a few minutes of prep, you’ll have a delicious and versatile sauce that you can use for pizza, pasta, and more. It’s so easy, you’ll wonder why you ever bothered with store-bought sauce.

11 of 20

Traditional Italian Bolognese Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Large Onion, Large Carrots, Celery

Traditional Bolognese Sauce - Culinary Ginger

The BEST Bolognese Sauce Recipe | foodiecrush.com

Traditional Bolognese Sauce | Recipe | Bolognese sauce, Bolognese ...

Authentic Italian Bolognese Sauce | Recipe in 2020 | Bolognese sauce ...

While not a traditional pizza sauce, Bolognese sauce is a delicious alternative that adds a meaty and savory element to any pizza. Our homemade recipe is made with ground beef, tomatoes, and a blend of herbs and spices, creating a rich and hearty sauce that is perfect for topping your Beer Can Chicken pizza.

12 of 20

Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Tomato Sauce, Tomato Paste, Garlic

Homemade Pizza Sauce - Recipes by Love and Lemons

Homemade New York-Style Pizza Sauce Recipe

For a no-fuss pizza sauce that packs a punch of flavor, our simple pizza sauce recipe is a must-try. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of dried herbs, this sauce is easy to whip up and can be used on any type of pizza. It’s a classic recipe that will never disappoint.

13 of 20

Italian Béchamel Sauce (White Sauce)

Main Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Milk, Ground Nutmeg, White Pepper

Creamy & Easy Bechamel Sauce - Anna in the Kitchen

If you’re a fan of white pizza or just looking to switch up your pizza sauce game, our Italian Béchamel sauce is a must-try. Made with butter, flour, and milk, this creamy and decadent sauce is the perfect base for any pizza. Top it with your favorite cheese and toppings for a deliciously rich and indulgent pizza.

14 of 20

Italian Arrabbiata Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic Cloves, San Marzano Tomatoes, Tomato

Spicy Arrabiata Sauce Recipe - Delish Knowledge

Sanniti Italian Arrabbiata Sauce, 12.3 oz

Italian Arrabbiata Sauce (sugo all'arrabbiata) | Recipe in 2021 ...

If you like your pizza on the spicier side, our Italian Arrabbiata sauce is the perfect sauce for you. Made with crushed red pepper, garlic, and tomatoes, this sauce packs a punch of heat and flavor that will take your Beer Can Chicken pizza to the next level. This sauce is also great for pasta dishes if you have any leftovers.

15 of 20

Alfredo Sauce

Main Ingredients: Heavy Cream, Unsalted Butter, Grated Parmesan Cheese

My Semi-Homemade Alfredo Sauce Recipe - Koti Beth

Make Creamy Alfredo Sauce with this secret ingredient

5 Ingredient Cream Cheese Alfredo Sauce Recipe - The Kitchen Magpie

Another non-traditional pizza sauce option, Alfredo sauce adds a creamy and indulgent touch to any pizza. Our homemade version is made with butter, cream, and Parmesan cheese, creating a rich and flavorful sauce that pairs perfectly with chicken and vegetables. Trust us, once you try Alfredo sauce on your pizza, you’ll never go back.

16 of 20

Pizza sauce

Main Ingredients: Medium Tomatoes, Small Onion, Tomato Sauce, Black

Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Better than Store Bought! Lil' Luna

Pizza Sauce Recipe With Fresh Tomatoes - Swasthi's Recipes

Sometimes, you just want a classic and simple pizza sauce that lets the toppings shine. Our basic pizza sauce recipe does just that. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and Italian seasoning, this sauce is easy to make and allows you to customize the flavors to your liking. It’s a great go-to sauce for any type of pizza.

17 of 20

Easy and Tasty Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomato Paste, Hot Water, Grated Parmesan, Minced

Sweetums Pizza Sauce- Slow Cooker Saturday | Cravings of a Lunatic

Pizza Dough & Quick Pizza Sauce – Eat Well

Easy Pizzeria Style Pizza Sauce - Real Life Dinner

For a pizza sauce that lives up to its name, try our easy and tasty pizza sauce recipe. Made with tomato paste, garlic, and a blend of herbs and spices, this sauce is full of flavor and comes together in minutes. It’s perfect for those busy weeknights when you want to make a homemade pizza without a lot of effort.

18 of 20

Homemade Marinara Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic Cloves, Fresh Basil Leaves, Crushed

Homemade Marinara Sauce - Homemade Hooplah

Homemade marinara sauce - vegan, gluten-free, customizable

THE BEST Homemade Marinara Sauce - foodiecrush.com

Marinara sauce is a classic Italian tomato sauce that is packed with flavor and perfect for pizza. Our homemade version is made with fresh tomatoes, garlic, and herbs, creating a sauce that is both bright and flavorful. Use it on your Beer Can Chicken pizza or save any leftovers for pasta dishes.

19 of 20

Simple Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Onion, Garlic Cloves, Dried Basil, Dried

Simple Neapolitan Style Pizza Sauce - Our Best Bites

Easy Homemade Pizza Sauce - Around The Nook

Pizza Sauce - The best easy pizza sauce! Once you try this super simple ...

Best Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - My Tasty Curry

For a simple and versatile pizza sauce that can be used in a variety of recipes, our homemade pizza sauce is the way to go. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of spices, this sauce is easy to make and can be customized to your taste preferences. It’s a great staple sauce to have on hand for any pizza night.

20 of 20

Italian Meatball Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic, Small Onion, Chopped Tomatoes, Dried

SUPER EASY VEGAN MEATBALLS IN ITALIAN TOMATO SAUCE - The clever meal

Italian Meatball Sauce - Daisies & Pie

Authentic Italian Meatballs & Sauce Recipe: An immersive guide by No ...

Last but certainly not least, our Italian meatball sauce is a delicious and unexpected pizza sauce option. Made with ground beef, tomatoes, and a blend of herbs and spices, this sauce adds a new level of flavor to any pizza. Plus, it pairs perfectly with the chicken in our Beer Can Chicken recipes for a tasty and unique pizza experience.

The Secret Behind Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza Sauce Recipe

The Perfect Blend of Ingredients

The key to Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza sauce is the perfect blend of ingredients. The sauce starts with a base of tomato puree, which provides the rich and tangy tomato flavor. To this, Italian herbs such as oregano, basil, and thyme are added to give the sauce its distinctive Italian flavor. The sauce is then seasoned with garlic and onion powder, giving it a savory and slightly sweet taste. Finally, a pinch of sugar is added to balance out the acidity of the tomatoes and bring all the flavors together.

A Slow and Steady Cooking Process

Papa John's takes their time in making their Italian Hero Pizza sauce to ensure that all the flavors are fully developed. The sauce is slowly simmered for several hours, allowing the flavors to meld together and creating a thick and rich sauce. This slow cooking process also intensifies the flavors, giving the sauce a depth of taste that cannot be achieved through quick cooking methods.

Quality Ingredients Make a Difference

Papa John's prides itself on using high-quality ingredients in all their recipes, and their Italian Hero Pizza sauce is no exception. The tomatoes used in the sauce are vine-ripened and hand-picked, ensuring that only the best and ripest tomatoes are used. The herbs and spices are also carefully selected and sourced from the finest suppliers. This attention to detail and commitment to using top-quality ingredients is what sets Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza sauce apart from others.

The Final Touch: Papa John's Special Seasoning

To add a unique and unforgettable taste to their Italian Hero Pizza sauce, Papa John's adds a special seasoning blend that is exclusive to their restaurants. This secret blend adds a burst of flavor that elevates the sauce and takes it to the next level. While the exact ingredients of this seasoning are a closely guarded secret, it is safe to say that it is a combination of herbs, spices, and other secret ingredients that give Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza sauce its signature taste. In conclusion, Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza sauce is a result of the perfect blend of high-quality ingredients, a slow cooking process, and a secret seasoning blend. By following these tips and using the right ingredients, you can recreate this delicious sauce at home and enjoy a taste of Papa John's Italian Hero Pizza anytime you want. So why not give it a try and impress your family and friends with your homemade version of this mouth-watering pizza sauce?