15 New York Italian Pizza Sauce Recipe Unleash Your Inner Chef!

Published on: Mar 18, 2024

New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce is a staple in the world of pizza-making. It is known for its rich and robust flavors, and perfectly balanced combination of sweet and tangy. The secret to a delicious New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce lies in its simplicity and high-quality ingredients. In this article, we will guide you through the steps of making a mouth-watering New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce that will elevate your homemade pizzas to a whole new level.

Jump to Recipe

1 of 20

Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Plum Tomatoes, Red Bell Pepper, Garlic, Tomato Paste

Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Honey and Birch

5-minute Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Crazy for Crust

If you're looking to elevate your homemade pizza game, it all starts with a delicious pizza sauce. And what better way to do that than with a homemade pizza sauce? Forget the store-bought stuff and whip up your own batch of this flavorful sauce.

2 of 20

The Perfect Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Unsalted Butter, Onions, Garlic Cloves

The Perfect Homemade Pizza Sauce ~ Recipe | Queenslee Appétit | Recipe ...

The Perfect Homemade Pizza Dough ~ Recipe | Queenslee Appétit

When it comes to pizza, the sauce is key. And this homemade pizza sauce is the perfect balance of tangy and sweet, making it the perfect base for any pizza topping combination you can dream up.

3 of 20

Ultimate Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Onions, Celery, Garlic Cloves

This ultimate pizza sauce recipe is a game changer. Made with a blend of fresh herbs, garlic, and tomatoes, it's packed with flavor and will take your pizza to the next level.

4 of 20

5-Minute Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomato Sauce, Tomato Paste, Garlic Cloves, Dried

5-MINUTË PIZZA SAUCË | Aimer La Cuisine

Easy 5 Minute Pizza Sauce | Recipe | Pizza sauce easy, Tomato pizza ...

5-Ingredient & 3-Minute Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe (Video ...

Short on time and need to whip up a quick pizza sauce? Look no further than this 5-minute pizza sauce recipe. With just a few simple ingredients, you'll have a delicious sauce in no time.

5 of 20

Best Ever Italian Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Fresh Oregano Leaves, Garlic

Authentic Italian Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - Christina's Cucina

Authentic Italian Pizza Sauce and Sicilian Pizza | What's Cookin ...

If you're a fan of traditional Italian flavors, then this is the pizza sauce for you. Made with a blend of herbs, garlic, and crushed red pepper, this sauce has the perfect balance of flavors to make your taste buds dance.

6 of 20

Super Easy Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Garlic, Italian Seasoning

Sweetums Pizza Sauce- Slow Cooker Saturday | Cravings of a Lunatic

Easy Pizza Sauce Recipe - Homemade Pizza Sauce - Life's Ambrosia

Easy Pizza Sauce Recipe - A quick homemade pizza sauce!

Don't have a lot of time to spend in the kitchen? No problem. This super easy pizza sauce recipe is perfect for busy weeknights. With just a few ingredients, you'll have a tasty sauce ready to go in minutes.

7 of 20

Traditional Italian Bolognese Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Large Onion, Large Carrots, Celery

Traditional Bolognese Sauce - Culinary Ginger

The BEST Bolognese Sauce Recipe | foodiecrush.com

Traditional Bolognese Sauce | Recipe | Bolognese sauce, Bolognese ...

Authentic Italian Bolognese Sauce | Recipe in 2020 | Bolognese sauce ...

Take your pizza game to the next level with this traditional Italian bolognese sauce. Made with ground beef, tomatoes, and a blend of herbs and spices, it's the perfect sauce for a meat lover's pizza.

8 of 20

Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Butter, Tomato Sauce, Tomato Paste, Garlic

Homemade Pizza Sauce - Recipes by Love and Lemons

Homemade New York-Style Pizza Sauce Recipe

This classic pizza sauce recipe is a must-have in your recipe collection. Made with just a handful of basic ingredients, it's simple yet packed with flavor. And the best part? It can be used for more than just pizza.

9 of 20

Italian Béchamel Sauce (White Sauce)

Main Ingredients: Flour, Butter, Milk, Ground Nutmeg, White Pepper

Creamy & Easy Bechamel Sauce - Anna in the Kitchen

Who says pizza sauce has to be red? Mix things up with this Italian béchamel sauce, also known as white sauce. Made with butter, flour, and milk, it's the perfect creamy base for your pizza.

10 of 20

Italian Arrabbiata Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic Cloves, San Marzano Tomatoes, Tomato

Spicy Arrabiata Sauce Recipe - Delish Knowledge

Sanniti Italian Arrabbiata Sauce, 12.3 oz

Italian Arrabbiata Sauce (sugo all'arrabbiata) | Recipe in 2021 ...

Looking for a pizza sauce with a kick? This Italian arrabbiata sauce is the perfect blend of spicy and flavorful. Made with tomatoes, garlic, and red pepper flakes, it's sure to give your pizza a little extra heat.

11 of 20

Pizza sauce

Main Ingredients: Medium Tomatoes, Small Onion, Tomato Sauce, Black

When it comes to pizza, the sauce is just as important as the toppings. And this homemade pizza sauce is a game changer. Made with a blend of herbs, garlic, and tomatoes, it's packed with flavor and will take your pizza to the next level.

12 of 20

Alfredo Sauce

Main Ingredients: Heavy Cream, Unsalted Butter, Grated Parmesan Cheese

My Semi-Homemade Alfredo Sauce Recipe - Koti Beth

Make Creamy Alfredo Sauce with this secret ingredient

5 Ingredient Cream Cheese Alfredo Sauce Recipe - The Kitchen Magpie

For a rich and creamy pizza sauce, look no further than this Alfredo sauce recipe. Made with butter, cream, and Parmesan cheese, it's a decadent alternative to traditional pizza sauce.

13 of 20

Easy and Tasty Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomato Paste, Hot Water, Grated Parmesan, Minced

Easy Pizza Sauce From Scratch- Amee's Savory Dish

Super Tasty Low-Carb Pizza Sauce - Delightfully Low Carb

This easy and tasty pizza sauce recipe is a must-try. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of Italian herbs, it's packed with flavor and takes just minutes to make.

14 of 20

Homemade Marinara Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic Cloves, Fresh Basil Leaves, Crushed

Homemade Marinara Sauce - Homemade Hooplah

Homemade marinara sauce - vegan, gluten-free, customizable

THE BEST Homemade Marinara Sauce - foodiecrush.com

For a classic and versatile pizza sauce, look no further than this homemade marinara sauce. Made with just a handful of ingredients, it's perfect for pizza, pasta, and more.

15 of 20

Simple Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Onion, Garlic Cloves, Dried Basil, Dried

Easy 5-Ingredient Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - A Clean Bake

Easy Homemade Pizza Sauce Recipe - The Dinner Bite

Easy Cheese Pizza with Homemade Pizza Sauce - Good Cheap Eats

Pizza Sauce - The best easy pizza sauce! Once you try this super simple ...

Sometimes simple is best, and that's certainly the case with this simple homemade pizza sauce recipe. Made with just a few basic ingredients, it's the perfect sauce for any pizza.

16 of 20

Italian Meatball Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic, Small Onion, Chopped Tomatoes, Dried

SUPER EASY VEGAN MEATBALLS IN ITALIAN TOMATO SAUCE - The clever meal

Italian Meatball Sauce - Daisies & Pie

Authentic Italian Meatballs & Sauce Recipe: An immersive guide by No ...

Take your pizza to the next level with this Italian meatball sauce. Made with ground beef, tomatoes, and a blend of herbs and spices, it's the perfect sauce for a meat lover's pizza.

17 of 20

Homemade Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Olive Oil, Garlic, Tomato Sauce, Diced Tomatoes, Tomato

For a classic and flavorful pizza sauce, this homemade pizza sauce recipe is a must-try. Made with a blend of herbs, garlic, and tomatoes, it's packed with flavor and will take your pizza to the next level.

18 of 20

Marinara Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Roma Tomatoes, Apple Cider Vinegar, Garlic, Sugar, Red

Marinara Sauce Recipe - Love and Lemons

Quick & Easy Marinara Sauce - Gal on a Mission

vegan-chipotle-marinara-sauce-pizza

This marinara pizza sauce is a staple in many kitchens, and for good reason. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of Italian herbs, it's simple yet packed with flavor.

19 of 20

Spicy Robusto Pizza Sauce

Main Ingredients: Tomatoes, Evoo, Cubanelle Peppers, Dried Basil Leaves

So good, the only pizza sauce recipe you'll ever need. Just like ...

Pizza Dough & Quick Pizza Sauce – Eat Well

EASY HOMEMADE PIZZA SAUCE Easy Homemade Pizza, Pizza Sauce Homemade ...

If you like a little heat in your pizza sauce, this spicy robusto pizza sauce is the one for you. Made with tomatoes, garlic, and red pepper flakes, it's sure to give your pizza a little extra kick.

20 of 20

Authentic (Quick) Italian Tomato Sauce for Pasta

Main Ingredients: Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Garlic, Italian Parsley

Authentic Italian Pasta Sauce - Quick Homemade Tomato Sauce - Christina ...

Cherry Tomato Pasta Sauce - Erren's Kitchen

Italian Pasta Sauce Recipes Authentic | Course Recipe

Homemade Italian Tomato Sauce! Homemade Spaghetti Sauce, Homemade ...

This quick Italian tomato sauce is perfect for not just pizza, but also pasta dishes. Made with canned tomatoes, garlic, and a blend of Italian herbs, it's a versatile sauce that can be used in a variety of dishes.

The Importance of a Good Pizza Sauce

A pizza sauce is the foundation of any great pizza. It is the base on which all other toppings are added and it sets the flavor profile for the entire pizza. A good pizza sauce should complement the crust and toppings, not overpower them. This is especially true for New York Style Italian Pizza, where the crust is thin and the focus is on the quality of the ingredients. A well-made pizza sauce is the key to achieving the perfect balance of flavors in every bite.

The Secret to a Delicious New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce

The secret to a delicious New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce lies in using high-quality ingredients and keeping the recipe simple. It starts with using San Marzano tomatoes, known for their sweet and tangy flavor. These tomatoes are grown in the volcanic soil of Mount Vesuvius in Italy and are considered the best for making pizza sauce. Crushed tomatoes are preferred over whole or diced tomatoes as they give a smoother consistency to the sauce. Fresh herbs and spices are essential for giving the sauce its signature Italian flavors. Oregano, basil, and garlic are the main players in this recipe. Make sure to use fresh herbs instead of dried for a more authentic and robust taste. The key is to balance the flavors, so don't be afraid to add more or less of a particular ingredient to suit your taste.

The Method

To make the perfect New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce, start by heating a generous amount of olive oil in a pan. Add minced garlic and sauté until fragrant. Add in crushed tomatoes and let it simmer for about 10 minutes. Then, add in the fresh herbs and let the sauce simmer for an additional 5 minutes. Season with salt and pepper to taste.
The Final Touch
To add an extra layer of flavor, many New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce recipes call for a pinch of sugar or a splash of balsamic vinegar. These ingredients help to balance the acidity of the tomatoes and bring out the natural sweetness of the sauce. Don't skip this step, as it can make a noticeable difference in the overall taste of your pizza sauce. In conclusion, a good New York Style Italian Pizza Sauce is all about quality ingredients and a simple recipe. With this easy-to-follow guide, you can now make your own homemade pizza sauce that will rival any pizzeria. So, next time you're craving a classic New York Style Italian Pizza, whip up this sauce and taste the difference.

Homemade Pizza Sauce

yield: 4 total time: 15 minutes

4.4 Stars (13 reviews)
View Recipe

Ingredients

14 1/2 ounces diced tomatoes undrained

6 ounces tomato paste

1 teaspoon sugar

1/2 teaspoon dried oregano

1/4 teaspoon garlic salt

1/2 teaspoon dried basil

1 pinch crushed red pepper

Nutrition

Calories : 60 calories

Carbohydrate : 14 grams

Fiber : 3 grams

Protein : 3 grams

Sodium : 340 milligrams

Sugar : 9 grams

Recipe Direction

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Comment

News & Trending

18+ Best White Christmas Cake Recipe Dive Into Deliciousness! Mar 22, 2024

20 Recipe Broccoli Salad Slaw Chinese Stir Fry Try These Culinary Delights! Mar 24, 2024

15 Homemade House Italian Dressing Recipe No Added Sugar Elevate Your Taste Buds! Mar 16, 2024

15 Japanese Fillet Steak Recipe Ignite Your Passion For Cooking! Mar 25, 2024

19 Lion's Mane Chinese Recipe Get Ready To Indulge! Mar 22, 2024

19 King Arthur Italian Flour Pizza Dough Recipe You Won't Believe The Taste! Mar 18, 2024

17 True Mexican Taco Recipe Cook Up Something Special! May 21, 2024

15 Best Chinese House Fried Rice Recipe Discover Culinary Perfection! Mar 22, 2024

17 Mexican Steak Seasoning Recipe Ignite Your Passion For Cooking! Mar 23, 2024

19 Chinese Peanut Cream Dessert Recipe They're Simply Irresistible! Mar 23, 2024

17 Chinese Vegetable Stir Fry Recipe Youtube You Won't Believe The Taste! Mar 24, 2024

20 Swedish Meatball Gravy Gravy Recipe They're Simply Irresistible! Mar 13, 2024

16 Pastrami Sandwich Recipe Russian Dressing Try These Culinary Delights! Mar 11, 2024

18 Fish Curry Recipe Pakistani Style Delight In These Amazing Recipes! Mar 6, 2024

19 Mexico City Hot Chocolate Recipe Delight In These Amazing Recipes! May 9, 2024

19 Italian Baked Fish With Tomatoes And Olives Recipe Get Cooking And Enjoy! Mar 16, 2024

18 Best Southern Sun Tea Recipe Unlock Flavor Sensations! Mar 28, 2024

15 Classic Chinese Fried Rice Recipe You Must Try Them! Mar 22, 2024

15 Best Enclidada Recipe Beef Pure Mexican Get Ready To Indulge! Apr 4, 2024

16 Turkish Coffee Recipe Reddit Get Ready To Indulge! Mar 11, 2024

You’ll Also Love

Turkish Recipes
20 Garlic Sauce Recipe Turkish Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

mexican recipes
16 Mexican Ancho Chili Sauce Recipe Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

Christmas Recipes
17 Beef Christmas Recipe Ideas Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

Japanese Recipes
18 Recipe For Japanese Fried Cabbage And Carrots Get Cooking And Enjoy!

Chinese Recipes
19 Chinese White Noodles Recipe Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

Southern Recipes
15 Best Southern Red Velvet Cupcake Recipe They're Simply Irresistible!

italian recipes
17 Italian Punch Recipe Non Alcoholic Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

Southern Recipes
19 Southern Living Recipe For German Chocolate Cake Delight In These Amazing Recipes!

Indian Recipes
16 Indian Chat Recipe Unlock Flavor Sensations!

Chinese Recipes
19 Chinese Bak Tong Go Recipe Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

Chinese Recipes
18 Chinese Beef And Bok Choy Recipe Discover Culinary Perfection!

Southern Recipes
18 Southern Sweet Potato Fries Recipe Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

mexican recipes
15 Mexican Citrus Chicken Marinade Recipe Unlock Flavor Sensations!

St Patrick's Day Recipes
19+ Rice Krispy Treats St Patricks Recipe Loaf You Must Try Them!

Turkish Recipes
20 Ground Beef Turkish Recipe Ignite Your Passion For Cooking!

italian recipes
20 Best Chicago Style Italian Beef Sandwich Recipe Unlock Flavor Sensations!

Holidays Recipes
18+ Holiday Rice Recipe Side Dish Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Chinese Recipes
20 Flakey Chinese Egg Tart Recipe Taste The Magic Today!

Vietnamese Recipes
18 Vietnamese Wrap Recipe Unleash Your Inner Chef!

Chinese Recipes
18 Easy Chinese Hot Dog Bun Recipe Cook Up Something Special!

Pakistani Recipes
16 Pakistani Bread Recipe Yeast Taste The Magic Today!

Indian Recipes
18 Turnip Green Recipe Indian Discover Culinary Perfection!

mexican recipes
17 Mexico Chiquito Cheese Dip Recipe Deliciousness Awaits You!

italian recipes
16 Publix 5 Grain Italian Bread Recipe Taste The Magic Today!

Japanese Recipes
16 Japanese Crouquet Recipe Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

Christmas Recipes
17 Christmas Stuffing Recipe With Sausage Meat Unlock Flavor Sensations!

mexican recipes
19 Instantpot Mexican Potato Recipe Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

Christmas Recipes
17+ Simple Glazed Christmas Ham Recipe Savor The Mouthwatering Goodness!

Southern Recipes
15 Southern Custard Recipe You Must Try Them!

Chinese Recipes
15 Chocolate Chip Cookies Recipe In Chinese Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Popular Recipes
15+ Corn Dip Recipes Dive Into Deliciousness!

Easter Recipes
19+ Gluten Free Easter Recipe Ideas Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

Chinese Recipes
17 Knorr Chinese Easy Recipe Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Indian Recipes
17 Ratatouille Recipe Indian Style Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

italian recipes
18 Traditional Italian Pizza Recipe Prepare To Be Amazed!

italian recipes
18 Chicago Italian Beef Sandwich Recipe Giardiniera Get Cooking And Enjoy!

mexican recipes
19 Mexican Molcajete Shrimp Recipe Dive Into Deliciousness!

Pakistani Recipes
20 Pakistani Naan Recipe Video You Must Try Them!

Chinese Recipes
16 Chinese Cabbage Zucchini Recipe Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

mexican recipes
15 Mexican Pickled Carrots Recipe Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

More Recipes Recipes
20 Cannelloni Recipe South Africa Dive Into Deliciousness!

Japanese Recipes
17 Recipe For Japanese Whole Fried Fish Get Ready To Indulge!

Chinese Recipes
17 Proper Chinese Curry Sauce Recipe They're Simply Irresistible!

4th July Recipes
15 4th Of July Picnic Recipe Ideas Experience Culinary Bliss Now!

Russian Recipes
20 Russian Breakfast Recipe Get Ready To Indulge!

More Recipes Recipes
18 Royal Icing Recipe For Cookies South Africa Dive Into Deliciousness!

mexican recipes
20 Mexican Cheese Dip Recipe Taste The Magic Today!

italian recipes
19 Italian Chili Soup Recipe Get Ready To Indulge!

Russian Recipes
15 Authentic Russian Vegetable Salad Recipe Taste The Magic Today!

Christmas Recipes
16+ Christmas Ranch Water Recipe Cook Up Something Special!

mexican recipes
20 Mexican Style Corn Recipe They're Simply Irresistible!

Valentine's Day Recipes
18+ Valentine Cookie Pops Recipe Prepare To Be Amazed!

Chinese Recipes
17 Chinese New Year Dumpling Recipe Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Holidays Recipes
19+ Brussel Sprouts Holiday Recipe Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Chinese Recipes
16 Rare Chinese Recipe Elevate Your Taste Buds!

mexican recipes
19 Recipe Video Mexican Sweet Cornbread Elevate Your Taste Buds!

Greek Recipes
18 Original Greek Baklava Recipe Ignite Your Passion For Cooking!

Southern Recipes
15 Easy Southern Stuffing Recipe Try These Culinary Delights!

Greek Recipes
20 Greek Salad Wrap Recipe You Must Try Them!

Indian Recipes
18 Best West Indian Rice And Peas Recipe Experience Flavor Like Never Before!

Swiss Recipes
17 Swiss Chalet Chicken Parmesan Recipe Discover Culinary Perfection!

Southern Recipes
18 Cornbread Pudding Recipe Southern Living Get Ready To Indulge!

Indian Recipes
18 Recipe Cucumber Tomato Onion Raita Indian Cook Up Something Special!

Indian Recipes
17 Mango Pickle North Indian Style Hing Recipe Unleash Your Inner Chef!