17+ Best Holiday Cookie Icing Recipe Cook Up Something Special!

Published on: Mar 1, 2024

Looking for the perfect icing recipe to elevate your holiday cookies? Look no further! We have tested and perfected the best holiday cookie icing recipe that will impress your friends and family. Get ready to create beautifully decorated and delicious cookies that will be the talk of your holiday gathering. From traditional Christmas sugar cookies to decadent gingerbread treats, this versatile icing recipe is guaranteed to elevate any cookie. So roll up your sleeves and let's get baking!

Jump to Recipe

1 of 17

Sugar Cookie Icing That Hardens

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Milk, Corn Syrup, Almond Extract, Food

Easy Sugar Cookie Icing Recipe that Hardens (easy & tasty!) - The ...

Sugar Cookie Frosting | TheBestDessertRecipes.com

Powdered Sugar Icing for Cookies - Design Eat Repeat

If you're a fan of sweet treats and indulgent desserts, then you've probably heard of the beloved sugar cookie. This classic cookie is a staple in many households, and for good reason - it's delicious, versatile and easy to make. But what really takes a sugar cookie to the next level? The perfect sugar cookie icing that hardens, of course. This simple yet essential addition can transform a basic sugar cookie into a work of art. And if you're looking for the best sugar cookie icing recipes around, you've come to the right place. Here are our top 17 picks for the best sugar cookie icing that hardens.

2 of 17

Easy Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Water, Food Coloring

Easy Sugar Cookie Icing (4-ingredients!) - Jessica Gavin

How To Decorate Cookies with 2-Ingredient Easy Icing | Kitchn

How To Decorate Cookies with Icing: The Simplest, Easiest Method ...

Let's start with a classic - easy cookie icing. This recipe is perfect for those who are new to baking or just want a simple yet tasty sugar cookie icing. With just four ingredients - confectioners' sugar, milk, light corn syrup, and vanilla extract - this icing is quick to make and produces a smooth, glossy finish. It's the perfect base for decorating with sprinkles, chocolate chips, or any other toppings you desire. Plus, it hardens nicely, making it a great option for packaging and gifting your sugar cookies.

3 of 17

Sugar Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Light Corn Syrup

Easy Sugar Cookie Frosting {that hardens, too!} - Belly Full

Easy Royal Icing Recipe for Sugar Cookies - Renee Romeo

Ultimate Royal Icing for Sugar Cookies - Pretty. Simple. Sweet.

For a traditional sugar cookie icing that hardens, look no further than this recipe. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and a touch of vanilla extract, this icing is simple yet effective. Its smooth consistency and ability to harden make it a great choice for any type of sugar cookie, whether it's cut-out shapes or drop cookies. Plus, it's versatile enough to add food coloring for a pop of color or flavor extracts for a unique twist.

4 of 17

The Best Sugar Cookie with Sugar Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Butter, Granulated Sugar, Eggs, Milk, Baking Powder

The Best Cookie Exchange Recipes | The Recipe Critic | Homemade sugar ...

Sugar Cookie Frosting Recipe - Shugary Sweets

Why settle for just a good sugar cookie when you can have the best? This recipe not only includes a delicious sugar cookie base, but also a fantastic sugar cookie icing that hardens. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and almond extract, this icing has a wonderful flavor that pairs perfectly with the sugar cookie. And with the addition of a little corn syrup, it produces a glossy finish that will make your cookies look like they came straight from a bakery.

5 of 17

Easy Sugar Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Water, Light Corn Syrup, Vanilla

Soft Christmas Cut-Out Sugar Cookies - Live Well Bake Often

For those who love a quick and easy recipe, this one's for you. This easy sugar cookie icing only requires two ingredients - confectioners' sugar and milk. It's a no-fuss option that still produces a beautiful and tasty result. Plus, it's perfect for those who want a thinner icing that spreads easily and hardens quickly. Feel free to add food coloring or flavor extracts to customize it to your liking.

6 of 17

Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Milk, Vanilla

Perfect Frosted Sugar Cookies - Cooking Classy

Sugar Cookie Icing (2 Ingredients) - Cleverly Simple

Looking for a sugar cookie icing that hardens but is also dairy-free? Look no further than this recipe. Made with confectioners' sugar, water, and light corn syrup, this icing is a great option for those with dietary restrictions. It's also a great choice for decorating cookies with intricate designs, as it hardens quickly and won't smudge or run. No matter your dietary needs, this icing is a delicious and easy option for your sugar cookies.

7 of 17

Glossy Sugar Cookie Icing (that hardens)

Main Ingredients: Confectioners Sugar, Light Corn Syrup, Milk, Almond

15 Best Ideas Sugar Cookie Icing that Hardens – How to Make Perfect Recipes

If you want an icing that is both glossy and hardens nicely, then this recipe is for you. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and meringue powder, this icing has a beautiful shine that will make your sugar cookies stand out. It's also great for decorating with intricate designs, as it hardens quickly and holds its shape well. For an extra special touch, add some edible glitter for a sparkly finish.

8 of 17

Sugar Cookie Icing for Cut Out Cookies

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Vanilla Extract, Water

The Best Sugar Cookie Frosting recipe - Boulder Locavore®

15 Cut Out Sugar Cookies Icing Anyone Can Make – Easy Recipes To Make ...

Christmas Cookies {Best Cut Out Sugar Cookie Recipe} – WellPlated.com

When it comes to cut-out sugar cookies, the icing is just as important as the cookie itself. This recipe is specifically designed for cut-out cookies, producing an icing that hardens and sets quickly to hold its shape. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and meringue powder, it's a simple yet effective recipe that will make your cut-out cookies look professional and delicious.

9 of 17

How to Make The Best (and Easiest) Sugar Cookie Icing...

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Milk

Sugar Cookie Icing - Preppy Kitchen

How to Make The Best (and Easiest) Sugar Cookie Icing (Glaze)- Cleverly ...

For a sugar cookie icing that is both easy and delicious, look no further than this recipe. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and vanilla extract, it's a classic combination that never fails. For those who want a thinner and more spreadable icing, add a little more milk. And for those who prefer a thicker and more opaque icing, add less milk. This recipe is versatile and can be adjusted to your liking, making it the best and easiest sugar cookie icing around.

10 of 17

Easiest Sugar Cookie Icing Ever

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Meringue Powder, Light Corn Syrup

Easiest Sugar Cookies - Completely Delicious

Best Sugar Cookie Frosting Ever | Recipe | Best sugar cookies, Sugar ...

As the name suggests, this recipe is the easiest sugar cookie icing you'll ever make. With only two ingredients - confectioners' sugar and milk - it's a great option for those who are short on time or just want a quick and tasty icing. It's also great for kids to help make and decorate their own cookies. For a fun twist, add some food coloring and let the little ones get creative with their designs.

11 of 17

Nutella Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Nutella, Powdered Sugar, Milk, Corn Syrup

Nutella Stuffed Cookies! - Jane's Patisserie

These Nutella S’more Cookie Sandwiches Are Going to Give You All the ...

Nutella Cookies Recipe (Only 4 ingredients) | Plated Cravings

Nutella Stuffed Easy Nutella Cookies – Butter Baking

For all the Nutella lovers out there, this one's for you. This unique recipe combines Nutella with confectioners' sugar and milk to create a delicious and creamy sugar cookie icing that hardens. It's perfect for those who want a little something extra on top of their sugar cookies. For an extra decadent treat, spread some Nutella on the bottom of your sugar cookies before adding this icing on top.

12 of 17

Best-Tasting Sugar Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Confectioners Sugar, Milk, Light Corn Syrup, Almond

Best-Tasting Sugar Cookie Icing | Recipe | Icing, Cookie icing, Icing ...

These beautiful cookies are the BEST tasting sugar cookie you will ever ...

If flavor is your top priority, then this recipe is for you. This sugar cookie icing not only hardens beautifully, but it also has a delicious vanilla flavor that will make your taste buds sing. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, vanilla extract, and almond extract, it's a winning combination that will take your sugar cookies to the next level. You can even add a little lemon zest for a refreshing twist.

13 of 17

Best Sugar Cookie Icing Ever

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Whole Milk, Light Corn Syrup, Almond

The Best Christmas Sugar Cookie Recipe (With Homemade Icing)

Best Sugar Cookie Icing Ever | Kitchen Meets Girl

For a sugar cookie icing that is truly the best ever, try this recipe. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and a touch of cream cheese, this icing not only hardens nicely but also has a creamy and tangy flavor that pairs perfectly with sugar cookies. It's a unique twist on traditional icing, and it's perfect for those who want to take their sugar cookies to the next level.

14 of 17

How to Make the Best Sugar Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Confectioners Sugar, Water, Pure Vanilla Extract, Corn

Sugar Cookie Recipe - Rachel J Mitchell

Easy Sugar Cookie Frosting Recipe - Jessica Gavin

For a foolproof and delicious sugar cookie icing recipe, look no further than this one. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, butter, and vanilla extract, this icing is creamy, flavorful, and hardens beautifully. It's a great option for those who want a little extra richness in their sugar cookies. You can even swap out the vanilla extract for different flavors like almond or peppermint.

15 of 17

All-Occasion Cookie Icing

Main Ingredients: Milk, Light Corn Syrup, Vanilla Extract, Powdered

The Best Sugar Cookie Recipe with Sugar Cookie Icing - Taste and Tell

Favorite Sugar Cookie Recipe | Favorite sugar cookie recipe, Sugar ...

Soft and delicious buttery shortbread cookies filled with strawberry ...

Whether it's Christmas, Halloween, or any other occasion, this recipe has got you covered. This all-occasion cookie icing is perfect for any holiday or celebration, as it hardens nicely and is easy to customize with different colors and flavors. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and corn syrup, it's a simple yet effective recipe that will make your sugar cookies look festive and delicious.

16 of 17

Easy Cookie Icing (Without Eggs)

Main Ingredients: Icing Sugar, Milk, Vanilla Extract, Salt, Food Coloring

Easy Royal Icing Recipe For Sugar Cookies - Unsophisticook

EDIBLE EGGLESS COOKIE DOUGH RECIPE - Grandma's Simple Recipes

For those with allergies or dietary restrictions, this recipe is a great option. Made without eggs, this easy cookie icing is perfect for those who are avoiding them or just want to try something new. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and corn syrup, it's a simple and tasty option for your sugar cookies. Feel free to add food coloring or flavor extracts to customize it to your liking.

17 of 17

The Best Cookie Icing Ever!

Main Ingredients: Powdered Sugar, Meringue Powder, Water, Oil, Glycerin

The Best Sugar Cookie Frosting-13 ⋆ Design Mom

Last but certainly not least, we have the best cookie icing ever. This recipe is a combination of all the best qualities of sugar cookie icing - it hardens nicely, has a delicious flavor, and is easy to make. Made with confectioners' sugar, milk, and meringue powder, it's a tried and true recipe that will never let you down. For an extra special touch, add some edible glitter or sprinkles on top.

The Secret to Perfect Holiday Cookie Icing

The Right Consistency

The key to achieving beautifully decorated cookies lies in the consistency of your icing. Too thin and it will not hold its shape, too thick and it will be difficult to spread. Our best holiday cookie icing recipe is perfectly balanced to provide the ideal consistency for decorating. The featured ingredient that makes all the difference is corn syrup. It helps to keep the icing smooth and glossy, making it easy to work with and giving your cookies a professional finish.

The Perfect Texture

Not only should your icing have the right consistency, but it should also have the perfect texture. Our featured ingredient of confectioners' sugar gives the icing a smooth and velvety texture, perfect for spreading and piping. It also adds a touch of sweetness to balance out the flavors of your cookies. For a richer flavor, you can also add a splash of vanilla extract to the icing.

Color and Flavor Variations

One of the best things about this best holiday cookie icing recipe is its versatility. You can easily customize the icing to suit your preferences and the type of cookies you are decorating. For a festive touch, add a few drops of red and green food coloring to create a classic Christmas color palette. Or, for a twist on traditional flavors, try adding a dash of cinnamon or peppermint extract to the icing for a subtle yet delicious flavor.

Expert Tips for Decorating

To achieve picture-perfect cookies, here are a few expert tips to keep in mind. When using food coloring, start with a few drops and add more as needed to achieve your desired color. Remember, a little goes a long way, and you can always add more, but you can't take it away. For more intricate designs, use a piping bag to create fine lines and details. And most importantly, have fun and let your creativity shine! Now that you have the secret to the perfect holiday cookie icing, it's time to get baking! Impress your loved ones with beautifully decorated and delicious cookies that are sure to spread holiday cheer. Happy baking!